This is the first question almost every Toronto property owner asks us, and the honest answer is: it depends on your property, your paperwork, and how much operational involvement you want. Here is the comparison, without the cheerleading.
A well-run short-term rental typically out-earns a lease by a wide margin. Our portfolio averages a $250 revenue-per-available-night at 80% occupancy, which puts a strong one-bedroom around $7,600 in gross monthly revenue against $2,400 to $2,800 on a long-term lease. Even after management, supplies, and higher utilities, nightly rentals usually win the raw revenue contest. We broke down the full math in what a Toronto Airbnb actually earns.
This is where the answer flips for many owners. Toronto’s bylaw restricts nightly rentals to your principal residence, caps entire-home rentals at 180 nights a year, and requires City registration. If the property is an investment unit you do not live in, the nightly Airbnb model is not legally available to you at all, and no revenue projection changes that. A long-term lease has no such restrictions.
A lease asks for a tenant search once a year or two. A short-term rental is a hospitality operation: pricing, messaging, cleaning turnovers, restocking, reviews, maintenance calls at check-in time. Self-managing is a part-time job. Professional management removes the workload but costs 10% to 20% per booking, which is exactly the trade our short-term rental management service exists to make worthwhile.
Short stays mean more foot traffic and more turnover wear, offset by frequent professional cleaning, guest screening, and platform damage protection. A lease carries a different risk profile: Ontario’s tenant protections make a problem tenancy slow and expensive to resolve, and a single non-paying tenant can erase a year’s worth of the revenue gap. Neither side is risk-free; they are just different risks.
Stays of 28 nights or more are exempt from Toronto’s short-term rental bylaw. Furnished mid-term rentals, priced well above long-term leases but below nightly rates, serve relocating professionals, insurance placements, and film crews. For principal residences, the winning pattern is usually nightly stays inside the 180-night cap plus mid-term stays for the rest of the year. For investment units, corporate and mid-term management captures most of the furnished-rental premium with none of the bylaw friction.
Choose nightly rentals if the property is your principal residence, you want maximum revenue, and you either enjoy hospitality operations or hand them to a manager. Choose a long-term lease if you want minimum involvement and the property is a pure investment unit you never want to think about. Choose the hybrid if you want furnished-rental economics on a property the bylaw excludes from nightly hosting, or you have hit the 180-night cap.
Not sure which column your property lands in? Book a free consultation and we will run the numbers for your specific unit, both ways, so you can decide with real figures instead of averages.
Share this post
Toronto property management and short-term rental specialists. We manage Airbnb, mid-term, and long-term rentals across the GTA.
